Fact check: Republican congresswoman didn't take credit for the relief bill she voted against
Washington (CNN)A Republican member of Congress, Rep. MarÃa Elvira Salazar of Florida, has faced withering attacks on Twitter for supposedly taking credit on Friday for a part of the American Rescue Plan, the pandemic relief bill she voted against.
A Republican senator, Roger Wicker of Mississippi, had been accurately criticized on similar grounds two days prior. But the criticism of Salazar is inaccurate.
Here are the facts.
On Friday, the day after President Joe Biden signed the $1.9 trillion American Rescue Plan into law, Salazar tweeted
the word "#BREAKING" with siren images around it, then wrote, "So proud
to announce that the Biden Administration has just implemented my
bipartisan COVID relief bill as part of @SBAgov policy!"
Salazar, a freshman member of the House, included a hyperlink
and an image that explained that she was talking about the Biden
administration's just-announced decision to give small businesses more
time to pay back Economic Injury Disaster Loans.
Many commentators assumed Salazar was applauding a part of the American Rescue Plan. But she was not.
Facts First: Salazar did not take credit for any part of the American Rescue Plan. Rather, the loan policy she was applauding was adopted by the Small Business Administration
separately from the American Rescue Plan. Salazar and a Democratic
colleague, Rep. Sharice Davids of Kansas, had proposed a very similar
loan policy in a bill
they put forward in early March. This Salazar-Davids bill is what
Salazar was referring to when she tweeted that the Biden administration
had implemented "my bipartisan COVID relief bill."
A White House official, National Economic Council Deputy Director Bharat Ramamurti, tweeted on Sunday to try to correct the inaccurate criticism of Salazar.
"I've
seen some confusion on this. On Friday -- separate from the American
Rescue bill -- SBA announced it was letting 3M+ businesses defer EIDL
loan payments for an extra year. We're glad to see bipartisan support
for this and other changes we've made to help small businesses,"
Ramamurti said.
The
Small Business Administration acted "under its own authority," in
consultation with the Biden-Harris team, to make the policy change --
not under the American Rescue Plan, a Small Business Administration
spokesperson said Monday on condition of anonymity.
Salazar could be accurately criticized for celebrating this one element of Covid relief after having rejected a broad array of other relief policies in the American Rescue Plan. And critics could accurately note that the American Rescue Plan she opposed includes billions in additional funding for small business loans and grants.
But
much of the criticism of Salazar's tweet was plain inaccurate. Critics
with six-figure or seven-figure Twitter followings -- including
California Democratic Rep. Ted Lieu; Fred Wellman,
executive director of the Lincoln Project, the conservative group that
campaigned against President Donald Trump; songwriter and activist Holly Figueroa O'Reilly; Markos Moulitsas, founder of the Daily Kos progressive political website; and journalist Soledad O'Brien -- wrongly alleged that Salazar was praising a bill she voted against.
Moulitsas, O'Brien and Wellman
promptly posted corrections after CNN reached out to them to explain
that they had been inaccurate. Lieu stood by his tweet, saying in a
message to CNN that he thinks that the American Rescue Plan, and the
provisions it does contain to bolster the emergency loan program, "gave
SBA confidence to do the extension" of the repayment period.
(CNN anchor Chris Cuomo tweeted a question on Sunday in response to Salazar's tweet praising the loan policy, asking on Twitter why she voted against the relief bill. On Monday, he tweeted that Salazar was correct that the loan policy is separate from the relief bill.)
It's not clear how much of a role Salazar, Davids or their bill's additional co-sponsors played in the Biden administration's decision. But their bill did precede the administration's announcement.
On March 3, Salazar and Davids introduced a proposal
in the House to extend the due date for the payment of interest and
principal on Economic Injury Disaster Loans -- to two years from the previous one year. The loans, totaling more than $200 billion, have been aimed at small businesses and nonprofits that had suffered a temporary revenue loss because of the pandemic.
On Friday, just over an hour before Salazar's celebratory tweet, the Small Business Administration sent out a press release
saying that it would extend the due date for the first payment -- to
two years for all Small Business Administration disaster loans made in
2020 and to 18 months for all such loans made in 2021.
No comments