Supreme Court blocks torture testimony sought by terrorism suspect held in Guantanamo Bay
(CNN)The Supreme Court said Thursday that the US government can -- in the name of national security -- shield the testimony of two former government contractors from a terrorism suspect who seeks to use the information in a criminal proceeding abroad.
Abu
Zubaydah, who the government says is a former associate of Osama bin
Laden, was subject to "enhanced interrogation techniques" in a CIA
detention center abroad and is now being held in Guantanamo Bay.
His
lawyers want to use the information to hold Polish officials
accountable for what Zubaydah says was his unlawful detention and
torture in a CIA facility in Stare Kiejkuty, Poland.
The
court's opinion could restrict access to materials, discovery or
testimony in future cases that the government claims should be protected
by a so-called "states secret" privilege meant to protect national
security.
"Today's
ruling will make it much harder, going forward, for victims of
government misconduct that occurs in secret to obtain evidence helping
to prove that the conduct was unlawful," said Steve Vladeck, CNN Supreme
Court analyst and professor at the University of Texas School of Law.
"Although
this case, specifically, is a narrow dispute about specific evidence
concerning the CIA's alleged torture of Abu Zubaydah in Poland, it's
likely to have far broader and more troubling ramifications going
forward."
The
Biden administration argued that it could block the testimony of the
former government contractors even though some of the information
Zubaydah seeks is already in the public realm.
The
case highlighted continuing terrorism concerns and examined the role
courts play balancing national security interests against calls for
greater transparency and government accountability.
No comments